good things - Liz Posmyk
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • My book
  • Writing & Media
  • FAQs

We will remember them...  an essay

23/4/2015

16 Comments

 
Poppies line the Roll of Honour at the Australian War Memorial in Canberra - image by Liz Posmyk
April 25 2015 marks the 100th anniversary of the day on which Australian and New Zealand Army Corps landed on the beaches of Gallipoli during the First World War. 

Unfortunately, over the last few weeks there's been much negative publicity about the "exploitation of Anzac Day" by big business, politicians and the media. And also the so-called "national obsession with Anzac Day", which critics feel has turned the day into a "celebration" or "circus" that costs Australian taxpayers more than $325 million.

Commentators have pointed out how businessmen and politicians seem to be "milking it for profit and ratings" (i.e. the poorly-devised ad campaign by Woolworths, the 24-page magazine and Anzac "coin" from News Corp, "special" wrap-around editions of newspapers etc). Others write about the cringeworthy way that pockets of Australians "get shit-faced [drunk], wear the Australian flag like a cape, stalk the streets yelling obscenities at foreign looking people, then gamble away money in pubs and clubs on the only day of the year when unregulated gambling is made legal". 

An esteemed friend and colleague of my generation is currently travelling in Turkey and wrote of his dismay at seeing young Aussies arriving there "sporting yellow polo shirts with ANZAC 2015 on them, as though they're off to support their team at a footy grand final". Indeed, ABC RN's stalwart Breakfast presenter, Fran Kelly, also currently in Turkey, mentioned this morning that the preparations for Anzac Day commemorations look more like the set up for a massive rock concert than a sombre gathering. Phillip Adams on RN's Late Night Live, also points out that "despite the Gallipoli Gallop [as he calls it], it wasn't the first [or only] battle that Australia has ever fought".

All of this, coupled with a full-day visit to the Australian War Memorial in Canberra recently, has made me reflect more deeply than usual about war in general, and what Anzac Day means to me, personally. Wars may perhaps be regarded as being 'honourable and noble', but conflict and war has caused vast losses and trauma across the globe throughout generations—and continues to do so to this day. Estimates on the number of people killed in war throughout history range between 150 million to a billion. But who really knows.

On Anzac Day, I am reminded of all wars and the senseless slaughter of fellow human beings, and the tragedy and sorrow that follows. I remember the WWII battle scars on my Hungarian father's body—a bullet wound in his shoulder and shrapnel wounds across his belly. The fact that he survived, and the things he must have witnessed. I remember a story my mother, a former nursing sister in Hungary, told me. She was on a train on her way to the hospital, when she was captured, detained and interrogated by German soldiers, before being allowed to go on her way. My parents, and their parents before them, were among the lucky ones to have survived war.

Although not Anzacs, my Peter's grandfather, George, lost his three brothers—John, Thomas and William—two of whom died in battle on the Western Front on the very same day, 26 April 1915. The third brother died from his injuries in a military hospital in London. Also killed in battle on 26 April 1915, that same day, were Peter's great grand uncle, and a cousin, both named Thomas. Five additional members of Peter's family (that we know of), including George Buckley (pictured below) died during the Great War. So much loss in just one family!

On Anzac Day, I will bake biscuits for Peter, who in the early 1980s served as an RAAF Peacekeeper in the Sinai Desert. Together we will watch the marches, and pause to give thanks to all of the men, women and children around the world touched by conflict. We will remember them.

2015 also marks the 40th anniversary of the end of the Vietnam War, and the 70th anniversary of the end of World War 2 in the Pacific. We will remember them.


Original grave marker for George Buckley killed at Flanders 8 July 1917 - image courtesy of the Buckley Family
Original grave marker for George Buckley killed at Flanders 8 July 1917. George is buried at the Poperinghe Old Military Cemetery, Belgium (image courtesy of the Buckley Family)
George Buckley killed at Flanders 8 July 1917 - image courtesy of the Buckley Family
George Buckley
16 Comments
Caroline link
21/4/2015 10:36:50 pm

Well said Liz. I was so fortunate to visit Gallipoli a few years ago and it was a much more moving experience than I expected it to be. But I am very glad I went on a quiet day when there was time to reflect and remember.

Reply
@ChristineSalins (FoodWineTravel) link
22/4/2015 02:42:52 am

Lovely post, Liz. Peter's family's experience echoes Maurie's so closely. They are even buried in the same region, and one of Maurie's great uncles also died in a military hospital in London (and is buried in England). You can't even begin to imagine what those families went through.

Reply
Liz link
22/4/2015 03:45:58 am

Thank you for this informative and sensitive post. War seems such a senseless and cruel way to resolve conflicts. My heart sometimes breaks that there is so much hatred, and fear, and anger.

I appreciate learning more about Anzac Day, with insights not seen in the mainstream media.

Reply
John/Kitchen Riffs link
22/4/2015 08:35:18 am

Really good post. Didn't realize Anzac Day had gotten so commercial -- that's really a shame. Excellent read -- thanks.

Reply
rea francis link
22/4/2015 11:16:05 am

Well said Liz! I too am appalled by the apparent commercialisation of Gallipoli - even to cruise ships offshore. Better to concentrate on the appalling British war office decisions of that time and indeed examine world history's lessons on wars to work towards preventing more.

History also depends on its recorders.

My partner Michael is German born and indeed is a survivor of the Dresden bombing at the end of the second world war .Only six at the time he has clear recollections of the inferno and to this day is indignant of history's recant on the thousands and thousands of civilians who perished there.

Reply
e / dig in hobart link
22/4/2015 12:47:57 pm

a thoughtful post. I am saddened that Anzac day has been commercialised and become a tourism industry, this year especially. I think that risks losing the message of these everyday men and what they did, but also, as you say, the brutal and horrific reality of warfare.

Reply
Maureen link
22/4/2015 01:58:32 pm

I think it was the Woolies campaign that got my attention and showed what a commercial endeavour it was. They weren't the only ones, as you point out.

Anyone who's spent time at the War Memorial in Canberra can see what it was like during war. It's not the glamourous, exciting adventure that these young men thought they were embarking on. All wars are awful.

Wonderful post, Liz.

Reply
Eha
22/4/2015 02:16:51 pm

Liz, thank you for the most evocative post anyone could possibly have written at this place in this time. You and I are first generation Aussies and we both are army brats it seems. I was going to try and 'compose' a somewhat fitting tribute to an incredibly special day in OUR history tomorrow for Saturday: I could not have done anywhere as well as you! When Saturday arrives at Gallipoli and in France we shall remember them with pride and in gratitude . . . . years back studying Australian history it was pointed out time and again that not the Federation but Gallipoli was the real beginning of what we now call 'Australia'. No, I do not like the flag used as a shoulder wrap . . . the rest I shall simply disregard as the stupid ignorance of those who do not understand. Lest we forget . . . . no way . . .

Reply
Deborah Harris
22/4/2015 02:43:59 pm

Well said.

A quote from a parliamentary library research publication records that:

“Rituals such as dawn services and street marches were developed, and gradually the families of the dead became quite marginalised... In Melbourne during the late 1920s, women, including mothers of those killed, were banned from the dawn service because of their wailing.”


Reply
Lizzy
22/4/2015 09:21:20 pm

Thank you, Deborah, thank you kindly. That is an interesting and heartbreaking record.

Reply
Hotly Spiced link
22/4/2015 04:07:29 pm

War is so senseless and those who orchestrate it are never, ever, on the front line. I'm so sorry to hear there has been so much loss in Peter's family; that's absolutely shocking. Like you, we will be paying tribute to all those Aussies and Kiwis who had no choice but were ordered into the wars, by attending a Dawn Service xx

Reply
Peter
22/4/2015 04:23:17 pm

My thanks to my 3rd cousin from England - Brian Henderson for the pics of my 1st cousin 2x removed George Buckley M.M and his grave markers. Brian and I 'discovered' each other through our genealogy research.....Thanks Brian.......

Reply
Tandy | Lavender and Lime link
22/4/2015 09:26:54 pm

It is so important to pay tribute to those who fought and those who still fight so that people can be free!

Reply
Anna @ shenANNAgans link
23/4/2015 07:31:32 pm

325 million..... WhaaaaaaT?! That's crazy.
I didnt realise it had become so commercial, mostly because we live in Canberra, and it's just what has always been a thing.
Good read Lizzy. Hope you enjoy your weekend. xo

Reply
David link
25/4/2015 02:50:26 am

It is always good to remember, and not use the remembrance as an excuse to party. We have all but forgotten the reason for our Memorial Day here... it has become yet another 3-day weekend in a slew of many. Thanks fro a beautiful and thoughtful essay, Liz.

Reply
Lizzy
7/5/2015 10:49:05 am

Thanks everyone for your very kind words and thoughts on this post.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Welcome...

    Üdvözölöm
    Photo of Liz Posmyk, Food Writer, Cook and Traveller

    ​Cooking and writing have been a lifelong passion.
    ​
    Join me as I share with you my favourite recipes; postcards and morsels from my travels; conversations with cookery writers
    and chefs; and news on food, cookbooks
    ​and cooking.
    ​
    - Liz Posmyk

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner


    All
    Anzac
    Apple Growers
    Australia
    Australian Producers
    Autumn
    Baking
    Beverages
    Biscuits
    Book Reviews
    Bread
    Breakfast
    Butter
    Cakes & Slices
    Canberra
    Charmaine Solomon
    Cheese
    Chestnuts
    Christmas
    Cocktails
    Coffee
    Conversations
    Cookies
    Cookware
    Cuisine Companion
    Curries
    Dairy Products
    Desserts
    Diet
    Dough
    Drink Blog
    Easter
    Edible Gifts
    Eggs
    Egg Safety
    Essays
    Events
    Favourite Flavours
    Fish
    Food News
    Food TV
    Food Verse
    Fruit
    Giveaways
    Good Things Favourites
    Growers & Producers
    Guest Post
    Health
    Hummus
    Hungarian Recipe
    Ice Cream
    In My Kitchen
    Kids In The Kitchen
    Kitchen Garden
    Markets
    Meat
    Muffins
    Musings
    My Book
    My Family
    New Year
    Noodles
    Nuts
    Observations
    Olives
    Pancakes
    Pasta
    Pastry
    Pepe Saya
    Pink Martini
    Pizza
    Polenta
    Postcards And Morsels
    Poultry
    Preserves
    Prize Giveaways
    Prunes
    Reminiscences
    Retro
    Reviews
    Rice
    Ricotta
    Salad
    Salads
    Sandwiches
    Sauce
    Seafood
    Slow Cooking
    Snacks
    Soups
    Stop Hunger Start Cooking
    Sydney
    Tefal
    Thanksgiving
    Thank You
    The Barber From Budapest
    Tofu
    Travel
    Truffles
    Tweatup510064f8ec
    Tzatziki
    Valentines Day
    Vegetables
    Vinnies Christmas Appeal


    NB: I use Australian standard measuring cups and spoons in my recipes. 

    Picture
    Winner ABC's 2015 Australia Cooks competition, ACT (mains category)
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Meet the Chefs - recipes featured on Australian Asparagus Council website

Good Things is written and published by Liz Posmyk © 2011-2020.   All rights reserved.
Excerpts may be used provided that full and clear credit is given. Thank you.


Photos from alantankenghoe, riptheskull, David Jackmanson, Amani Hasan, SuntanMidori, oropeza, Annie Mole, Vegan Feast Catering, avlxyz, jeffreyw, mockstar, jenly, Syeefa Jay, pizzodisevo (therapy - terapia - Therapie), ginnerobot, cliff1066™, Jim, the Photographer
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • My book
  • Writing & Media
  • FAQs